Yesterday I was reading Rixa's children-in-public-spaces at Stand and Deliver and loved her eloquent take on something that seems to be a controversial topic lately after the original Feministe article and the response my-child-takes-up-spaceon Womanist Musings. Do children belong in public space? Are they/ their parents expected to maintain a particular code of conduct compatible with adult-only world? And is it elitist and priviledged (and by extension "unfeminist") to suggest that adults have a right to quiet or child-free spaces? I love the way Rixa summed it up: "How we treat children--our own as well as other people's--speaks volumes about our core values as a society. Children are our most vulnerable group, dependent on the adults around them. They deserve to be nurtured, loved, guided, and most of all, accepted as a normal part of what it means to be human."
I want to look at this from the perspective of special needs children who fit into both disadvantaged classes simultaneously. My little man is more than 2, less than 3; thanks to fighting some serious medical disadvantages is not quite acting age appropriate in every way. He does go out in public. I consider him a person equally deserving of all experiences that are not dangerous to him. We go to parks, parties, stores, etc.. He also sometimes has snacks when some might consider it a food-inappropriate moments. Only in the last few months has he learned to start feeding orally. I bring his favorite snacks and water bottle everywhere for every time he might feel like practicing his new skill.
We still communicate pretty non-verbally and he does get frustrated and "temper tantrumish" when he can't express what he wants and sometimes this happens in public. One day a month ago, we were out in the car and had no more Cheetohs left, which was a crisis. We stopped at a grocery store and he excitedly walked all the way to the junk food aisle where we picked up the bag. Then he freaked out and decided that I had to hold him. I did not think that was necessary as he is perfectly capable of walking and needs a little encouragement to do more on his own. I told him "If you walk to that aisle down there, I'll pick you up" The whole way down, I'd walk a little in front of him and get him to come a few steps, carefully avoiding getting close enough for him to grab on and try to force me to pick him up. On the way, he was fussing (not disturbing anything at this big loud store.) An employee made an acknowledging face at me and I laughed and said "he wants cheetohs!" He said "I'm just glad its not mine. I have a 3 yr old and 5 yr old"
I think he meant to convey understanding, but it still hit me the wrong way. I wasn't upset or overwhelmed (though it happens on occasion.) I've dreamed of the day that he would be alive and not on any drips or oxygen and walking in a public space and even expressed himself (even if by crying instead of actual dialog.)
I guess to me, the heart of the issue is this: For any person, adult or child, that you may encounter, you really don't know. You can't look and determine the chronological age of a kid and therefore what behaviors should be appropriate. For any person, you cannot necessarily see superficially what their abilities are, the same way you cannot look at someone's race and know everything about their upbringing and culture. Instead of running around being the "appropriate public behavior" police on each other, couldn't we all just promote a society of respect for all people that we encounter? Can we learn to share this space?
this is a really fascinating dialogue to me... it reminds me of a story a friend of mine told at Passover this year. A Rabbi of a certain synagogue was getting flack from his congregation about the disruptive nature of having children in the service. His response was, "after the Holocaust the sound of a crying baby, is the sound of another baby that is still with us."
ReplyDeletethanks for sharing your thoughts. I enjoy reading your stuff
Love the extra angle this brings to the discussion! Here are some other ways this applies: I was very tall for my age and generally mature. But sometimes I "acted my age" (had to put it in quotes, because it sounds so judgmental!). People would frown on such a big girl acting like a baby, and my mom would have to explain that I was a baby. I also think people just progress and develop at different rates, even when they haven't had physical or developmental challenges. I know my cousin, for instance, is 12 but acts more like 8 or 10, and she got a lot of criticism at a family reunion for being immature. But, you know, they're only kids once! I agree that it's not helpful to assign appropriate behavior to kids, even if you think you know what they should be doing at a certain stage.
ReplyDeleteLove Maeret's comment. That gave me chills.
Maeret - I love that story. I really wish we had a society overall that valued the contributions of children more.
ReplyDeleteLauren - I think that's an excellent point. Being large or small brings another set of expectations on how a child is supposed to conduct themselves. Reminds me how a heart mama with a child that was pretty malnurished/small (as tends to happen to our sweet heart kiddos) would get comments all the time about "wow that baby can talk!"